India’s semiconductor dream: No to foreign investment (1950-1984)

The lingering memories of foreign exploitation, coupled with a cautious approach to foreign investment, led to downfall.

Introduction:


India’s trajectory in the semiconductor industry is a testament to the delicate balance between self-reliance and strategic foreign investment. This blog post delves into two pivotal instances from the mid-20th century that shaped India’s semiconductor journey. The rejection of proposals from British electronics company Ferranti and semiconductor pioneer Fairchild Semiconductor, along with India’s eventual strides in the field, offer a nuanced perspective on the challenges and opportunities of technological development.

Ferranti’s Vision and India’s Quest for Independence (1950s)


The 1950s marked a crucial period in India’s history as it navigated the path to independence and self-reliance. Amidst these aspirations, Ferranti, a British electronics company, proposed a visionary plan to establish a computer manufacturing plant in Bangalore. The offer entailed a transfer of technology and expertise from Ferranti, complemented by funding from the Indian government. Despite the potential advantages, the Indian government hesitated due to multifaceted concerns.

The lingering memories of foreign exploitation, coupled with a cautious approach to foreign investment, led to skepticism about Ferranti’s proposal.

The Indian government’s belief in the nation’s engineers and scientists fueled the conviction that India could independently develop its computer industry. Furthermore, the estimated cost of the project, amounting to billions of rupees, raised financial apprehensions.

While this decision held India back from an early entry into the computer industry, it underscored the nation’s resolve to assert autonomy and avoid potential exploitation. However, the hindsight reveals the missed opportunity to expedite India’s technological progress through strategic collaboration.

Follow us on Linkedin for everything around Semiconductors & AI

Fairchild Semiconductor’s Pursuit and Indian Bureaucratic Challenges (1960s)

In the 1960s, the semiconductor industry was on the cusp of revolutionizing technology, offering prospects for rapid advancement. Fairchild Semiconductor, a prominent player in integrated circuit technology, contemplated establishing its first Asian unit in India. However, the Indian government’s bureaucratic hurdles and reservations regarding technology transfer deterred Fairchild from pursuing this opportunity within India’s borders.

The Indian government’s fears about sensitive technology being diverted to military applications, a desire to protect domestic electronics, and a lack of complete understanding of the semiconductor industry contributed to the unfavorable climate for Fairchild’s proposal.

Moreover, the Indian bureaucracy’s inefficiency and the imposition of high import duties on semiconductor equipment created an environment that was unfavorable for foreign investment.

Consequently, Fairchild Semiconductor opted for Malaysia and the Philippines, shifting the trajectory of semiconductor manufacturing away from India. This instance served as a stark reminder of the necessity for an enabling environment that balances safeguarding national interests with facilitating foreign collaborations.

Robert Noyce’s Visit and the Dawn of Possibilities (1969)

The late 1960s witnessed a glimmer of hope when Robert Noyce, a luminary in the semiconductor industry, explored the prospects of setting up a semiconductor manufacturing facility in India. Having co-founded Fairchild Semiconductor and Intel, Noyce’s visit held immense promise for India’s technological advancement.

Noyce was only allowed to set up a fab that would not exceed hundreds of thousands of chips, which was not economically viable.

Unfortunately, India’s stringent regulations on foreign investment restricted Noyce to a project that lacked economic viability. Despite Noyce’s stature as a pioneer in the field, the constraints hampered India’s potential to leapfrog in semiconductor technology

Bankruptcy to Trillion-Dollar Company: Story of Nvidia – techovedas.

Semiconductor Complex Limited (SCL) and India’s Determined Progress (1970s)

The 1970s marked a turning point for India’s semiconductor journey with the establishment of the Semiconductor Complex Limited (SCL). Recognizing the need for domestic capabilities in semiconductor design and fabrication, the Department of Electronics (DoE) initiated this venture. SCL aimed to leverage foreign expertise and technology while nurturing India’s indigenous capabilities.

Despite initial foreign assistance, SCL paved the way for India’s semiconductor aspirations. A panel of experts shortlisted two locations – Mohali and Madras – for SCL. While Madras initially seemed favorable, Punjab Chief Minister Zail Singh’s intervention secured the opportunity for Mohali. This decision, though controversial at the time, emphasized the importance of highly skilled personnel in semiconductor manufacturing.

Conclusion:


India’s semiconductor journey is a tapestry woven with missed opportunities and pivotal decisions. The rejection of Ferranti and Fairchild Semiconductor’s proposals underscored India’s caution and protection of national interests. However, they also delayed India’s entry into the semiconductor industry, highlighting the importance of striking a balance between self-reliance and strategic foreign collaboration.

The eventual establishment of SCL in Mohali showcased India’s determination to embrace foreign technology and expertise while nurturing its own capabilities. As India continues its journey in the semiconductor industry, these historical instances serve as guiding lights, emphasizing the significance of prudent evaluation of foreign investment proposals to ensure national growth, technological prowess, and global leadership.

Part 2- India’s semiconductor dream: Burnt with SCL (1984-2006)

Editorial Team
Editorial Team
Articles: 1899