TSMC Halts Chip Shipments to Sophgo Following Huawei Processor Discovery

Research firm TechInsights uncovered TSMC's chip during a teardown of Huawei’s Ascend 910B.

Introduction

Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company (TSMC), the world’s leading contract chipmaker, recently suspended shipments to Chinese chip designer Sophgo after discovering a TSMC-manufactured chip on Huawei’s Ascend 910B AI processor.

The incident has raised questions regarding potential export control violations and drawn the attention of both Taiwan and U.S. authorities. Amid intensifying U.S.-China tech tensions, the decision underscores the ongoing complexities facing the global semiconductor supply chain.

Key Points:

  1. TSMC Suspends Shipments: TSMC cut off shipments to Sophgo following the discovery of a TSMC chip on a restricted Huawei processor.
  2. TechInsights Discovery: Research firm TechInsights uncovered TSMC’s chip during a teardown of Huawei’s Ascend 910B.
  3. U.S. Export Restrictions in Focus: The U.S. imposed strict export controls in 2020 to limit Huawei’s access to chips made with American technology.
  4. Sophgo Denies Links to Huawei: Sophgo asserted that it has no business ties with Huawei and is fully compliant with all legal regulations.
  5. Implications for the Industry: The incident highlights the increasing scrutiny on Chinese tech firms amid U.S.-China tensions.

TSMC’s Shipment Suspension Raises Red Flags in Tech Supply Chain

On October 26, sources revealed that TSMC, Taiwan’s largest and most influential semiconductor producer, had halted shipments to China-based chip designer Sophgo.

The suspension came after researchers at TechInsights discovered a TSMC-made chip embedded within Huawei’s Ascend 910B processor.

The processor, which powers some of Huawei’s AI applications, raises red flags due to the stringent U.S. export controls that ban the supply of certain foreign-made semiconductor technology to Huawei.

According to Reuters, TSMC reported the discovery to both Taiwanese and U.S. authorities, flagging a possible breach of international trade regulations.

Although TSMC ceased shipments to Huawei following the 2020 U.S. export control expansion, this incident indicates how complex and potentially circumventable these restrictions can be.

TechInsights Uncovers the Chip

TechInsights, a prominent tech research firm, first discovered the TSMC chip during a recent teardown analysis of Huawei’s Ascend 910B processor.

Known for its comprehensive product analysis, Tech Insights disassembled the AI processor and identified the TSMC-manufactured chip at its core.

Upon learning of the discovery, TSMC quickly alerted relevant authorities and suspended shipments to Sophgo, which had allegedly ordered the chips.

This rapid response illustrates TSMC’s commitment to compliance with export regulations, especially those impacting sensitive markets like AI and advanced computing.

U.S. Export Restrictions on Huawei: A Brief History

The U.S. government has closely monitored exports to Huawei, implementing sweeping restrictions in 2020 to prevent the company from accessing cutting-edge technology produced with American intellectual property.

Under these rules, any technology reliant on U.S.-sourced software, equipment, or components falls under strict control, even if produced abroad.

Since then, companies like TSMC that previously supplied chips to Huawei have been prohibited from fulfilling any orders involving American technology.

TSMC’s advanced nodes, which power everything from high-performance AI to telecommunications devices, are regarded as critical in upholding these controls.

The U.S. restrictions, however, present challenges in monitoring and tracing chips once they leave the production line.

Sophgo’s Statement: “No Connection to Huawei”

In response to TSMC’s shipment suspension, Sophgo released a statement denying any business relationship with Huawei.

The company emphasized its compliance with all legal requirements and stated that it has provided a detailed investigation report to TSMC.

Notably, Sophgo is linked to cryptocurrency mining company Bitmain and has faced scrutiny in Taiwan for allegedly recruiting local semiconductor talent and conducting unauthorized research and development.

According to Sophgo, it acquired TSMC’s chips for its own product line and claims no knowledge of how a TSMC chip ended up in a Huawei device.

Despite the denial, TSMC’s decision to halt shipments demonstrates a cautious approach in navigating geopolitical pressures and international regulations.

China’s IC exports hit RMB 736.04 billion, reflecting a 24.8% rise year-on-year | by techovedas | Sep, 2024 | Medium

Industry Implications Amid Growing U.S.-China Tensions

This incident underscores the growing complexities within the global semiconductor industry as firms grapple with compliance across multiple jurisdictions.

As technology firms become enmeshed in geopolitical tensions, supply chain transparency and traceability are increasingly essential to prevent breaches of export restrictions.

For TSMC, maintaining adherence to U.S. export controls is paramount, given its reliance on American equipment for chip production.

For Chinese tech firms like Sophgo and Huawei, obtaining high-performance semiconductors is becoming increasingly difficult due to these restrictions.

This discovery raises questions about the resilience of the tech supply chain and whether additional safeguards might be necessary to prevent unauthorized technology transfers.

The ongoing tug-of-war over technology access is a crucial aspect of the U.S.-China trade relationship, with semiconductors at its heart.

Analysts predict that as the industry matures, further incidents involving potential export violations may arise, prompting calls for stricter oversight and transparency.

TSMC’s Response and Regulatory Landscape

TSMC, a leader in advanced chip manufacturing, has been transparent in its compliance efforts and collaboration with U.S. authorities.

In a statement earlier this year, the company confirmed that it had not supplied Huawei since the 2020 restrictions took effect.

TSMC has also underscored its commitment to regulatory compliance, actively engaging with the U.S. Department of Commerce to stay informed on export policy changes.

For its part, Huawei denies using TSMC’s chips post-2020, but the presence of the Ascend 910B processor in the market suggests a continued demand for high-performance AI solutions that Huawei cannot produce domestically at the same level.

Nvidia Tops Apple as World’s Most Valuable Company with $3.53 Trillion Valuation Driven by AI Boom – techovedas

Taiwan and U.S. Collaboration on Export Enforcement

Both the U.S. and Taiwan have enhanced their collaboration on export control enforcement to safeguard semiconductor technology from unauthorized use.

Taiwan, home to TSMC and other chip industry leaders, is particularly sensitive to these issues due to the role its technology plays in both consumer electronics and military applications.

Industry insiders believe that both Taiwan and the U.S. may increase scrutiny of supply chain management processes to ensure that chips produced within Taiwan remain compliant with export restrictions, especially as Chinese tech firms seek to close the technology gap.

Intel vs. AMD in the PlayStation 6 Chip Contract Bid and Its Broader Impact on Intel’s Foundry Strategy | by techovedas | Sep, 2024 | Medium

Conclusion

The TSMC-Sophgo shipment halt exemplifies the far-reaching effects of U.S. export controls on the global tech industry.

TSMC’s quick action demonstrates its commitment to compliance, while the case spotlights the challenges of maintaining supply chain integrity amid geopolitical tensions.

As the tech industry continues to grow and evolve, close collaboration between governments and companies will be essential to ensure that cutting-edge technologies remain secure and compliant with international trade laws.

Kumar Priyadarshi
Kumar Priyadarshi

Kumar Priyadarshi is a prominent figure in the world of technology and semiconductors. With a deep passion for innovation and a keen understanding of the intricacies of the semiconductor industry, Kumar has established himself as a thought leader and expert in the field. He is the founder of Techovedas, India’s first semiconductor and AI tech media company, where he shares insights, analysis, and trends related to the semiconductor and AI industries.

Kumar Joined IISER Pune after qualifying IIT-JEE in 2012. In his 5th year, he travelled to Singapore for his master’s thesis which yielded a Research Paper in ACS Nano. Kumar Joined Global Foundries as a process Engineer in Singapore working at 40 nm Process node. He couldn’t find joy working in the fab and moved to India. Working as a scientist at IIT Bombay as Senior Scientist, Kumar Led the team which built India’s 1st Memory Chip with Semiconductor Lab (SCL)

Articles: 2304